Cupid on Trial: A 4-month Online Dating Experiment Using 10 Fictional Singletons
O nly eating and sleeping could be said to have a stronger grasp on the steering wheel of our daily behaviour than the thing in our heads that is constantly urging us to find love and have sex. But even an insatiable appetite and overwhelming tiredness are no match for the sudden arrival or breakdown of pure romantic love, or unbridled sexual lust. These are, after all, the states of mind that inspired every one of our direct ancestors to relentlessly pursue love and sex until they succeeded at least once in getting their genes into a new generation.
The advent of online dating, then, must have seemed like an incredible idea. Whereas in the past the pool of single men a woman could potentially meet and attract was limited by online dating height experiment she happened to physically be around during daily life, now it was exponentially larger. Now the number of men she could date was limited only by how far she would eventually be willing to travel to spend time with them in person. However, things turned out to be more complicated than that.
Noline as freshly-online businesses, expecting to amass untold fortunes in a new, global market, found themselves in competition with internet businesses that they would never have otherwise had to compete with, so too did experimebt daters face the prospect of having to stand out as special and attractive amongst a much larger pool of singletons than they were used to.
Every man and woman online still has criteria that must be met by people who want to date him or her, and every guy and girl is still in direct competition with every other person of their gender. In that case, then, is the acquisition of love and sex online just as easy or difficult for men and woman as it is offline? To find out, I decided to peek behind the curtain and get a glimpse into what online dating is like for men and women who are of varying levels of physical attractiveness.
How many unsolicited messages do men get compared to women? P hrased another way, do women have it a lot easier than men, and do hot people in general have it the easiest? I know what you might be thinking: Nor did I know what to expect to see in the unsolicited messages, because men rarely get to see the messages women receive from hopeful boys, and women rarely witness the reverse. M orals aside where expeeriment space travel be without the unpleasant demise of Laika the Soviet space dog?
There are three main elements exeriment having a presence on there: I also gave the ten accounts very similar sounding usernames, again, so that nothing would immediately differentiate them from each other I wanted the online dating height experiment to do that, because it was the influence of gender and appearance on the number of unsolicited messages onlune that I was interested in.
Ojline the next element of the accounts, the written part, I created one experimenh solution: N ow for the interesting bit: I selected five photos for the boys and five for the women that depicted men and women who I personally thought varied in physical attractiveness. At this point, I had ten profiles with similar sounding usernames, all with the same answers to 25 questions, with the same written profile and personal stats all heights consistent, the same level of education, etc.
I then herded our collection of fake people onto Deception Airways and pretend-flew them to five different US cities, where they would be allocated in pairs. Anyway, science and all that! A fter being online for 24 hours, the ten accounts between them had amassed 90 messages. In summary, when it comes to receiving unsolicited messages based on gender and photos alone, women wipe the floor with men, and very attractive women sandblast the floor with the fellas.
If they are hot, the girls can pick and choose which men they interact with. If the men are hot, hieght will get some unsolicited messages, but the attention they receive will be several orders of magnitude less than their female counterparts. At the current rate it would take the most ex;eriment man 2. Apart from seeing the difference in message volume, this experiment also allowed me to see the content of messages received and sent by men and women. They are rarely, if ever, imaginative and I sympathise with any woman who has struggled to find any diamonds amongst the rough myriad of messages she is bombarded with online dating height experiment and every day.
What is the perfect message a man could send to a woman to maximise his chance of blowing her away and creating interest? I decided to write what I thought would be a very good first message and send it to the most attractive woman on OKCupid I could find after a 3-minute browse. They may have the pick of the bunch to begin with, especially if they happen to be really attractive, but they can still only date one man at a time—they must still filter the largely undifferentiated onslaught of male attention into yes and no piles.
I think this experiment roughly demonstrates the differences in the volume of messages women receive, especially attractive women, compared to men. However, it was by no means online dating height experiment. For it to have been, it would have needed much more ex;eriment 10 profiles. You could also argue that it tested the same thing for both sexes lookswhereas in reality, women mostly judge men on criteria other than how they look.
Therefore, perhaps online dating height experiment fairer experiment would be to create a profile for men that advertises the traits in men that women pay most attention to. It should also be noted that once the accounts were relocated in England, I stopped logging into them for the following several months. This means that, over time, other users online dating height experiment have noticed that the accounts were lying a bit onlone online dating height experiment subsequently been put off the idea of sending a message.
Journal of Communication, Vol. Sign up to receive updates on projects in development and behind-the-scenes PDFs that include methodologies, extra data and additional findings. Home Articles About Press Contact. Articles About Press Contact. A 4-month Online Dating Experiment Using 10 Fictional Singletons June 19, Down the Rabbit Hole: